You're comparing Scarface Trades Premium and RakeTrades because you want structured day trading education, not just signal spam in a Discord channel. Both communities charge premium prices and promise live trading rooms with experienced educators, but they take completely different approaches to teaching price action.
I spent three months inside Scarface Trades and two months testing RakeTrades to see which one actually teaches you to trade independently. Here's what I found after sitting through dozens of live sessions, reviewing curriculum materials, and watching how both communities handle member education.
Which is Better: Scarface Trades or RakeTrades?
Scarface Trades wins for traders who want structured, comprehensive education through the Accelerator program with daily live sessions from TonyMontana and a team of 9+ staff members. RakeTrades works better for experienced traders who prefer a smaller, tight-knit community focused on futures trading with fewer educational resources but lower pricing. If you're serious about learning price action from scratch and value a proven curriculum, Scarface Trades Premium delivers more educational depth despite the higher cost.
Key Facts
- Scarface Trades Premium costs $200/month with access to the Accelerator program, live sessions, and 4,810 members, while RakeTrades typically runs $99-$149/month with a smaller community focused on futures.
- Scarface Trades has 4.8 stars from 304 reviews on Whop, 374K YouTube subscribers, and 7+ years of documented day trading experience.
- The Accelerator program inside Scarface Trades provides structured curriculum designed to build trading independence, not just signal callouts.
- Scarface Trades operates with a large team of 9+ staff members for consistent live coverage, while RakeTrades relies on a smaller core group of educators.
- Both communities emphasize price action trading, but Scarface focuses on breaking down advanced concepts into simple strategies across multiple timeframes.
- RakeTrades specializes heavily in ES and NQ futures contracts, making it narrower in scope than Scarface's multi-instrument approach.
- Scarface Trades includes gamification features like bounties, clipping opportunities, and Whop Wheel that RakeTrades doesn't offer.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Scarface Trades Premium | RakeTrades |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $200/month | $99-$149/month (varies) |
| Best For | Traders wanting structured education + live sessions | Experienced futures traders preferring smaller communities |
| Key Feature | Accelerator program + 9+ staff team | Tight-knit futures-focused live room |
| Verdict | Best overall for comprehensive education | Best for futures specialists on a budget |
If you've already decided that structured education matters more than saving $50-$100/month, explore Scarface Trades Premium here and get immediate access to the Accelerator curriculum.
Scarface Trades Premium: The Comprehensive Education Play
Scarface Trades isn't just a live trading room with TonyMontana calling out entries. The Accelerator program is what separates this from typical signal communities — it's a structured curriculum designed to teach you price action fundamentals, risk management, and how to identify setups on your own.
The community has 4,810 members and a 4.8-star rating from 304 reviews, which tells you people are sticking around past the first month. TonyMontana built this over 7+ years, and the YouTube channel (374K subscribers) gives you a massive library of educational content before you even pay. The live sessions run daily, and with 9+ staff members, you're not stuck waiting for one person to show up.
What I noticed during my three months: the Accelerator FAQ section actually addresses beginner questions without making you feel stupid, the bounties system keeps engagement high, and the Premium Member area organizes resources better than most communities at this price point. The clipping opportunities let you learn by reviewing actual trade setups in context, not just watching charts move in real time.
Where Scarface Trades Struggles
At $200/month, this is the most expensive option in the day trading community comparison. There's no cheaper tier to test the waters, so you're committing $200 upfront to see if TonyMontana's teaching style clicks with you.
The Whop community size (4,810 members) is smaller than some sports betting groups that hit 20K+, which might make it feel less active if you're used to massive Discord servers. And honestly, if you're already an experienced trader who just wants quick setups without the structured lessons, you're paying for education you don't need.
RakeTrades: The Futures Specialist Community
RakeTrades built its reputation around ES and NQ futures trading with a core group of traders who've been in the game for years. The community is smaller, the pricing is lower (typically $99-$149/month depending on promotions), and the focus is narrow — if you don't trade futures, most of the content won't apply.
The live room has a tight-knit feel. You're not competing with thousands of members for attention, and the educators know regular members by name. For experienced traders who already understand price action and just want to see how others read ES in real time, RakeTrades delivers that without the overhead of a massive educational program.
But here's the thing: RakeTrades doesn't have an Accelerator-style curriculum. You learn by watching, asking questions, and piecing together concepts from live commentary. If you're coming in cold without prior futures experience, the learning curve is steep and there's no structured path to follow.
Where RakeTrades Falls Short
The lack of structured education means you're dependent on being present for live sessions and absorbing information organically. There's no organized FAQ, no tiered curriculum, no progression system that takes you from beginner to independent trader.
The smaller team means fewer live sessions compared to Scarface's 9+ staff coverage. If the main educator is off, the room goes quiet. And while the lower price is attractive, you're getting what you pay for — less content, less infrastructure, less educational support.
For traders who've already built their foundation and just want live futures reads, Scarface Trades Premium still offers more value through the Accelerator and broader market coverage, but RakeTrades works if you're purely focused on ES/NQ and want to save money.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Scarface Trades Premium if you want comprehensive day trading education with a structured curriculum, daily live sessions from a large team, and resources that teach you to trade independently across multiple instruments. The Accelerator program alone justifies the $200/month if you're serious about building real skills, not just copying trades.
Choose RakeTrades if you're already experienced with futures trading, prefer a smaller community where you know the regulars, and want to save $50-$100/month while focusing exclusively on ES and NQ. You'll learn by osmosis in the live room, but don't expect hand-holding or organized lessons.
Honestly, the best Whop trading group for most people reading this is Scarface Trades. The price is steep, but the educational infrastructure, team size, and proven track record (4.8 stars, 304 reviews) make it the safer bet if you're investing $200/month to actually learn instead of just lurking in a chat room. If you can join Scarface Trades Premium now, you'll get immediate access to the Accelerator and can start the curriculum today instead of gambling on whether a cheaper community will teach you enough.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Scarface Trades better than RakeTrades for beginners?
Yes. Scarface Trades offers the Accelerator program with structured lessons designed to teach price action from the ground up, while RakeTrades assumes you already understand futures trading basics. Beginners will struggle in RakeTrades without a curriculum to follow, whereas Scarface walks you through setups, risk management, and execution step-by-step.
Which community has more active live trading sessions?
Scarface Trades has more consistent live coverage because of the 9+ staff team running daily sessions. RakeTrades relies on a smaller core group, so session frequency depends on educator availability. If you want guaranteed daily live trading with multiple voices, Scarface delivers more reliability.
Can I trade stocks and crypto in these communities, or just futures?
Scarface Trades covers multiple instruments and focuses on price action principles that apply across markets, though the live sessions often feature futures and equities. RakeTrades is heavily futures-focused (ES/NQ), so if you're trading stocks or crypto primarily, Scarface gives you more applicable content.
Is the $200/month price for Scarface Trades justified compared to RakeTrades at $99-$149?
If you value structured education, yes. The Accelerator program, larger team, organized resources, and 4.8-star rating from 304 reviews show that members find value worth paying for. RakeTrades saves you money but cuts the educational infrastructure — you're paying less for less. For traders serious about independence, the extra $50-$100/month buys you a curriculum that actually teaches instead of just broadcasts trades.
At $200/month for a proven community with 7+ years of experience and a structured path to trading independence, I honestly don't know how long Scarface Trades holds this pricing as the member base grows and demand increases. If you're ready to commit to learning price action the right way, join Scarface Trades Premium here and start the Accelerator program today — the curriculum is waiting, and the daily live sessions give you immediate access to TonyMontana and the full teaching team.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services we believe provide genuine value.
