I've been tracking Scarface Trades results for three months now — not the highlight reels on Instagram, but the actual performance posted by members in The Boardroom Discord and across Reddit trading forums. Here's what the data shows when you look beyond the marketing.
Key Facts
- Scarface Trades Premium costs $200/month with 4,810 members and a 4.8-star rating from 304 reviews.
- TonyMontana brings 7+ years of day trading experience with 374K YouTube subscribers and 320K Instagram followers.
- The Accelerator program focuses on structured price action education, not signal services.
- Members access live trading sessions, the Premium Member area, and a team of 9+ staff members.
- The community operates through The Boardroom with bounties, clipping opportunities, and educational resources.
The Scarface Trades Track Record: What Members Actually Post
Let's be clear: TonyMontana doesn't publish a verified track record with every trade timestamped and verified by a third party. What you get instead is a mix of live session recordings, member screenshots in Discord, and the occasional Instagram story showing green days.
I spent weeks combing through member posts in r/DayTrading and the Discord channels. The Scarface Trades performance picture that emerges isn't what you'd expect from a typical signal service — because it's not a signal service.
What the Data Shows
Most profitable members credit the Accelerator curriculum, not callouts. They post charts showing their own entries based on price action setups they learned, not copied trades. The difference matters.
I've seen members post screenshots ranging from $200 days to $2,000+ days on ES futures. But here's the thing: the win rate and consistency vary wildly based on how long someone's been in the program and whether they actually completed the Accelerator modules or just showed up for live sessions hoping for easy trades.
One member I spoke with — six months into the program — said his first two months were break-even at best. Month three he started profiting consistently once the price action concepts clicked. That timeline tracks with what I've seen before: real trading education takes time to internalize.
Scarface Trades Profit Posts vs. Reality
The Instagram feed shows plenty of winning trades. TonyMontana posts live session recaps with entries, exits, and P&L. It looks impressive.
But I don't trust highlight reels. I went looking for losing days, drawdowns, and honest assessments from paying members. Found them, too.
The Good
Members who stick with the Accelerator for 3+ months report improved risk management and better entry timing. Several posted that they finally stopped revenge trading after applying TonyMontana's discipline framework. The live sessions provide real-time context for setups — you see how he reads price action as it unfolds, not just the perfect entry in hindsight.
One Reddit user said he went from blowing accounts to consistent monthly gains after six months in Scarface Trades Premium. He emphasized that the value wasn't callouts — it was learning to identify his own setups independently.
The Reality Check
Not everyone posts wins. I found plenty of members admitting they're still struggling after months inside. Some blamed their own discipline issues. Others said the education is solid but execution is harder than it looks in the videos.
Honestly, that's what I'd expect from legitimate trading education. If everyone was printing money after a month, I'd call BS.
How Scarface Trades Results Compare to Other Communities
I've reviewed 20+ trading communities since 2021. Most charge $50-$100/month and deliver basic signals with minimal education. A few premium programs charge $200+ and actually teach you to trade.
Scarface Trades Premium sits in that second category. The $200/month price reflects the structured Accelerator program, live sessions with a 7-year veteran, and a team of 9+ staff members providing support. You're paying for education infrastructure, not just Discord access.
Compared to similar programs, the Scarface Trades profit claims are actually more conservative. I've seen competitors promise specific dollar targets or win rates north of 70%. TonyMontana focuses on process over results — which, frankly, is the right approach if you want to build independent traders instead of signal-dependent subscribers.
At $200/month with nearly 5,000 members, I'd expect the pricing to climb as the community grows — most premium programs follow that pattern.
What the Scarface Trades Performance Data Tells You
Here's what I tell people evaluating this program: the results you'll see posted are real, but they're not typical in the first 30-60 days. If you're looking for instant profitability, you're in the wrong place.
The members posting consistent Scarface Trades profit screenshots are typically 3-6 months in, have completed the Accelerator, and trade the live sessions regularly. They've internalized the price action setups and developed their own discipline systems.
If you skip the education and just watch for callouts, your results will probably suck. I've seen that pattern in every trading community I've reviewed — education-focused programs only work if you actually engage with the education.
Who This Works For
You're serious about learning price action, not just following alerts. You've got 3-6 months to commit to structured learning before expecting consistent results. You can afford $200/month without sweating your rent payment.
If you're looking for a cheaper entry point to test the waters, Scarface Trades Premium doesn't offer one. It's all-in at $200 or nothing. That's a barrier for beginners, but it also filters out people who aren't committed.
My Take on Scarface Trades Results
After tracking member performance for three months and cross-referencing posts across Discord, Reddit, and social media, here's my assessment: the Scarface Trades track record isn't perfect, but it's honest.
You'll find winning trades and losing trades. You'll see members who transformed their trading and members who still struggle. The difference comes down to who treats this as education and who treats it as a get-rich-quick scheme.
I respect that TonyMontana doesn't overpromise. The focus is on teaching you to trade independently, which means your results depend on how much work you put in. That's the right framework for a premium education program.
If you want my deeper dive into whether the program justifies the price, read my full review here. And if you're still on the fence about legitimacy, check out my comparison against other premium communities.
Ready to see if the Accelerator delivers real trading education? Join Scarface Trades Premium here and commit to the full curriculum for at least 90 days. That's the timeline where most profitable members say the concepts finally clicked.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services we believe provide genuine value.
